Products you buy through our links may earn us a commission. Oh, and if something's out of stock, oops, it was there (and all prices were accurate) at time of publication.
Welcome to Skimm Tested, a series where we put viral products to the test and give you our honest, unfiltered reviews.
What I Tested…
Miss Mouth’s Messy Eater Stain Pen, $13.99/2-pack
How I Tested…
I swapped out my usual Tide stick for this stain-removing pen. I kept it on hand over the course of the last four months, using it to treat any unexpected stains. I tried it out on my white couch too.
Why I Tested…

My Results…
Ease of use. Just like competing stain-removing pens, this one has a chiseled tip for precise scrubbing. When you press down, it’ll deposit a solid amount of product.
Design. No disrespect, but I have always found Tide sticks to be unsightly in my bag. The design of Miss Mouth’s is cute and sleek with fun illustrations that allow it to stand out. Just like any other stain stick, it’s compact and easy to travel with.
Stain-removing power. This is what really got me. The stain-removing power on this is unreal and exceeded my expectations. It works quicker than the Tide pen does and doesn’t leave a dried, noticeable ring around the stain (which is my biggest gripe with Tide). The biggest wow-factor for me was when I used this to get a small chocolate stain out of my white couch — it instantly disappeared.
Ingredients. Miss Mouth’s only has seven ingredients, all of which are easy to read and understand. For a product that I’m putting so close to my body (that sometimes comes in contact with my skin), I appreciate that. I find with the Tide pen, I can sometimes get itchiness or irritation surrounding the area where I’ve treated the stain.
Scent. The Tide stick has a strong chemical scent. Because of that, I don’t find it enjoyable to use if I’m going to treat a stain and then go about my day in that garment. Miss Mouth’s has no noticeable scent, making it basically undetectable.
Price. Yes, Miss Mouth’s is actually cheaper than Tide. You can get a pack of two stain-removing pens on Amazon for $13.99, making each stain remover pen come out to around $7. A single Tide stick goes for $9.99.
Sidenotes…
Miss Mouth’s Messy Eater comes in full sizes, too.
It’s free of peroxide, chlorine, phosphates, formaldehyde, sulfates, perfumes, and dyes.
It’s water-based, and Safer Choice certified, making it a solid option for kids and toddlers.
The Fine Details…
You can shop select Miss Mouth’s products at Amazon and Target.
Miss Mouth’s Messy Eater Stain Pen, $13.99/2-pack






